Understanding executor fees is crucial whether you are drafting a will or appointed as an executor. Executor fees are the compensation an executor receives for executing a will, but these fees aren't guaranteed and vary significantly between states, with some states having maximum fee limits.
Several states have laws in place that set maximum limits on executor fees, while others leave it to the discretion of the court or the terms laid out in the will. This divergence in regulations creates a diverse landscape of executor fees across the U.S.
In this article, we'll focus on New York, where executor fees are set by statute, providing a predictable framework for executors and beneficiaries alike. Our aim is to provide clarity on the often complicated subject of executor fees in New York, helping you navigate the process with confidence.
Executor Fees in New York
In New York, unlike many other states, executor fees are explicitly defined by law. The Surrogate’s Court Procedure Act provides a sliding scale for executor compensation, which serves as a guideline for understanding what an executor can expect to receive.
The sliding scale is as follows: 5% on the first $100,000 of the estate's value, 4% on the next $200,000, 3% on the next $700,000, 2.5% on the next $4 million, and 2% on anything above $5 million. These percentages are applied to both the incoming assets and the outgoing payments, essentially rewarding the executor for both collecting the estate's assets and distributing them to beneficiaries.
While the law provides a clear guideline, it's important to note that these percentages are not absolute. The court has the discretion to increase or decrease the fee if it deems it necessary, considering the complexity of the estate and the work involved. For example, if the estate is particularly complex or if the executor has performed duties above and beyond the norm, the court may allow for additional compensation.
Executor fees in New York are paid from the estate's assets, meaning the executor is compensated before the remainder of the estate is distributed to the heirs. Given the standardized fee structure in New York, disputes over executor fees are less common than in states where the fees are more subjective. However, beneficiaries can still contest the fees if they believe they are unreasonable.
Claiming Reasonable Expenses as an Executor
In addition to the executor fee, New York law allows executors to claim "reasonable expenses" incurred during the administration of the estate. These are costs that the executor has paid out-of-pocket while fulfilling their duties.
These reasonable expenses can cover a wide range of costs, including administrative expenses like postage for mailing documents, travel costs for meetings or court appearances, and professional fees for attorneys, accountants, or appraisers. If the executor has to maintain a property as part of the estate such as paying for necessary repairs, utilities, or insurance, these costs can also be considered reasonable expenses.
For an expense to be deemed 'reasonable,' it must be necessary for the administration of the estate. Extravagant or unnecessary costs may not be approved by the court and could be challenged by beneficiaries. The process for claiming these expenses typically involves the executor keeping detailed records and receipts, which are then submitted to the probate court for approval. In some cases, the executor may need to justify the expenses, particularly if a beneficiary disputes them.
Tax Implications of Executor Fees
One important factor to consider when dealing with executor fees and reasonable expenses is their tax implications. In general, executor fees are considered taxable income, and they must be reported on the executor's personal income tax return. They are reported as income, not self-employment, so executors do not have to pay self-employment tax on them.
On the other hand, reimbursed expenses are typically not taxable as long as they are necessary costs incurred while administering the estate and are reimbursed directly by the estate. These expenses should be kept separate from fees for tax purposes.
The executor will receive a Form 1099-MISC from the estate reporting the amount of compensation received during the tax year. This form should be included when filing personal taxes.
When Do Executors Get Paid?
The process of settling an estate can be lengthy, and executors may wonder when they will receive compensation for their work. In New York, executors are typically paid before beneficiaries receive their inheritances, but the timing can vary.
Generally, executors receive their fees once they have completed most of their duties, which often includes tasks like settling debts, paying taxes, maintaining properties, and distributing assets to beneficiaries.
However, before the executor's fee is paid, it must be approved by the probate court. This involves the executor submitting a detailed account of their time and expenses, which the court reviews to determine if the requested fee is 'reasonable.' Once the court approves the fee, the executor can then pay themselves from the estate's assets.
Remember, the probate process can take several months to over a year, depending on the complexity of the estate. Therefore, executors should be prepared for the possibility that their compensation may not be immediate. Consulting with an estate planning attorney will help understand the specific timeline and processes involved in your situation.